Second to Shakespeare in the Park,
Mystery Plays was DS' cheapest theater selection of the week- at least for students. Difficult it is to complain about $10 theater but pursuant to DS' no shame policy..... voila:
The Mystery Plays are the work of young playwright Reoberto Aguirre Sacasa who could benefit from the services of an editor/ muse- someone to seek out in his
oeuvre the poor overworked cliches deserving of lonely retirement:
"the grave stones look like teeth" (yawn)
"you have been chosen" (oy)
"we are all on the journey that is life" (vogon poetry).
Lines like these have no business appearing in effective ghost stories. Lines like these should be caught and shot before suffering actors are required to speak them without wincing.
Which is not to suggest that playwright Aguirre Sacasa does not have inspired moments. As the
Voice noted, in essence, the kid has vision. It seeps through the plot (which by the way, could be tightened). His blend of campfire stories, medieval mythology and the everydayness of it all is sometimes chilling, sometimes beautiful. Aguirre-Sacasa likes to bring the world of his horror stories close to ours. He likes to create horror right next door, today, this century, to people similar to ourselves. He likes to have his characters speak to us directly.
"You'll never guess what kind of ghost I met on the way to Newport..."
There is, however, something very tiresome about the Blair Witch/ capturing the Friedmans/ infomercial/ documentary style he uses. (Character: I am on a train. I am going to Newport. There is a handsome man next to me. I am going to see my family. I wonder if I can get laid). There is a time for soliloquy, but not in ALL scenes. Sometimes the audience wants to talk to the characters and sometimes they should shut up, already. The fourth wall will not shatter if the characters have never gotten behind it in the first place? [VLADIMIR: I am a character. I am waiting for Godot. This is all I do. Estragon is my friend. That's all. Waiting]. Of play and playwright, this is just a case of stunted development.
Within the constraints of this petri dish theater, the actors delivered laudable performances, especially Mark Margolis, majestic and magical in his role as Mister Mystery (an unfortunately named character, not an ice cream cone) - too bad about the Freddy Kruger outfit.
Special, special kudos for Daniel Baker, S. Ryan Schmidt, Sandra Goldmark, creators of beautiful, innovative scene, sound and light effects that sometimes perfectly captured the Mystery Plays' ghostly moods, and sometimes carried the play through its trying moments. If you find yourselves on the upper west side, consider seeing the play, if only for the masterful scenography. Peak in also for Aguirre-Sacasa's inspiration. He might be someone to watch when he lets his characters tell their own stories and dusts the cliches off his often gleaming language-
and finally, come for the
McGinn/Cazzale theater, officially DS' current winner of the DS Best Venue Award for comfort, set up and space management. Just try to see as well in the back row at Mamma Mia.
Where to get your Pre-Theater Wine
"Bar" bar (Broadway, between 79th and 78th streets, East side).
You'll find that there are better bars, there are seedier bars, and there are dirtier bars than this one, all of which is not a reason to go.
The terrace of the Greek Restaurant across the street from the theater
On 78th Street. Good wine, Good reviews, smoking spaces and sexy service. (DS has heard their whole grilled fish is an after-theater feast).
AND FINALLY....
The Faun Rating: 4.0/10 for: Required much more wine
(0 = like getting root canal,
9.9= almost as good as it gets without gratuitous nakedness.
10 = contains gratuitous nakedness)
The Faun Scale: Still as a board... breathing deeply... purring... Slightly more alert during first half, when faun smiles were observed.